Tenant Insurance Requirements: What Landlords Should Require

Every commercial lease creates a risk-sharing arrangement between landlord and tenant. The tenant occupies the space, conducts business operations, invites customers and employees onto the premises, and modifies the property to suit their needs. The landlord retains ownership of the building, maintains common areas, and bears ultimate premises liability for the property. Without proper insurance requirements written into the lease and enforced through COI verification, the landlord absorbs risk that should belong to the tenant.

The gap between what most landlords require and what they should require is significant. Too many leases contain vague insurance language — "tenant shall maintain adequate insurance" — that provides no enforceable standard. This guide covers the specific coverages, limits, and endorsements that landlords should require from every commercial tenant.

---

Commercial General Liability: The Foundation

The standard CGL requirement for commercial tenants is $1,000,000 per occurrence / $2,000,000 general aggregate. This has been the industry baseline for over two decades, and while some risk managers argue it should be higher given inflation, the $1M/$2M standard remains the most widely accepted minimum.

What CGL Covers for the Landlord

The tenant's CGL policy covers third-party bodily injury and property damage arising from the tenant's operations. When a customer slips on a wet floor inside a tenant's retail space, the tenant's CGL responds first. When a tenant's employee leaves a door propped open and a third party is injured in the common area, the tenant's CGL may respond depending on the additional insured endorsement language.

Per-Location Aggregate

For tenants with multiple locations, request a per-location aggregate endorsement (CG 25 04 or equivalent). Without it, the tenant's $2,000,000 aggregate applies across all locations. A tenant operating five retail stores could exhaust their aggregate on a claim at another location, leaving zero aggregate available for claims at your property.

Products-Completed Operations

If the tenant manufactures, processes, or sells products from the premises, the products-completed operations aggregate becomes critical. A food service tenant, for example, needs products coverage for foodborne illness claims that may arise after customers leave the premises.

---

Damage to Rented Premises

This coverage — formally called "Damage to Rented Premises (Each Occurrence)" on the ACORD 25 — is one of the most important and most frequently under-required coverages in commercial leasing. It covers physical damage to the specific premises the tenant occupies, typically triggered by fire, explosion, or other covered perils.

Standard Limits

The limit should reflect the actual replacement cost of the specific space the tenant occupies, including landlord-owned fixtures, finishes, and building systems within the demised premises. A tenant occupying a newly renovated space with $400,000 in tenant improvements should not carry $100,000 in damage to rented premises coverage.

Common Mistake: Confusing DRP with the Landlord's Property Policy

Damage to rented premises coverage on the tenant's CGL is not a substitute for the landlord's building property policy. It is supplemental coverage that allows the landlord to recover the cost of repairing fire damage to the tenant's specific space without filing a claim on the building's master property policy (which would increase the landlord's loss history and premiums).

---

Business Personal Property

Business personal property (BPP) coverage protects the tenant's own equipment, inventory, furniture, and fixtures. While BPP does not directly protect the landlord, requiring it serves two important purposes.

First, it prevents the tenant from making claims against the landlord's property policy. After a fire or water damage event, an uninsured tenant may argue that the landlord's negligence (deferred maintenance, inadequate fire suppression) caused the loss and attempt to recover the value of their destroyed business property from the landlord's policy. If the tenant has their own BPP coverage, their carrier pays first and may subrogate against the landlord if negligence existed — but the immediate financial pressure on the tenant is reduced, which reduces litigation risk.

Second, BPP coverage contributes to the tenant's business continuity. A tenant who loses all their equipment and inventory without insurance is a tenant who stops paying rent. The landlord's interest in the tenant's financial survival after a loss event is real and direct.

Standard BPP requirements vary by tenant type, but the lease should require the tenant to maintain BPP coverage at replacement cost value (not actual cash value) sufficient to cover their contents.

---

Naming the Landlord as Additional Insured

The additional insured requirement is the single most important insurance provision in a commercial lease. Without it, the tenant has insurance but the landlord has no direct rights under that policy.

Who Should Be Named

The additional insured endorsement on the tenant's CGL policy should name:

• The property owner — by exact legal entity name (including LLC, LP, Inc., or Trust designation)
• The property management company — if a third-party manager is engaged
• The mortgage holder — if the lender requires it as a condition of the loan

The exact language matters. "ABC Properties" is not the same as "ABC Properties, LLC" or "ABC Properties, LP." A mismatch between the entity named on the certificate and the entity that actually owns the building can create coverage gaps if the carrier challenges additional insured status during a claim.

Which Endorsement Form

The preferred endorsement is CG 20 26 — Additional Insured — Designated Person or Organization. This form provides the broadest protection, covering the landlord for liability arising out of the ownership, maintenance, or use of the premises by the tenant. Alternative endorsements like CG 20 11 (Managers or Lessors of Premises) also work but provide slightly narrower coverage.

Primary and Non-Contributory

The lease should require that the tenant's GL policy be primary and non-contributory with respect to the landlord's own GL policy. Without this language, the tenant's carrier and the landlord's carrier may dispute which policy pays first, delaying claim resolution. The primary and non-contributory endorsement (CG 20 01 or equivalent, or blanket language in the policy) ensures the tenant's policy responds first and does not seek contribution from the landlord's policy.

---

Workers' Compensation

Any tenant with employees on-site must carry Workers' Compensation at statutory limits as required by the state where the premises are located. The lease should require:

• Statutory WC coverage with no exceptions
• Employers' Liability at $500,000 each accident / $500,000 disease — policy limit / $500,000 disease — each employee (minimum)
• Waiver of subrogation in favor of the landlord on the WC policy

The waiver of subrogation is important. Without it, if a tenant's employee is injured on the premises due to a building condition (a broken stair, a malfunctioning elevator), the WC carrier pays the employee's claim and then surogates against the landlord to recover the payment. The waiver prevents this subrogation, keeping the WC claim within the WC system rather than shifting it to the landlord's GL policy.

Tenants Without Employees

Some tenants — solo practitioners, single-member LLCs — claim to have no employees. In most states, sole proprietors and certain corporate officers can exempt themselves from WC requirements. The lease should require these tenants to provide either a state-issued WC exemption certificate or a signed affidavit attesting to their exemption status. Do not accept a verbal assertion.

---

Commercial Umbrella

The umbrella requirement should scale with the tenant's risk profile:

Tenants with liquor service should carry Liquor Liability coverage either as a standalone policy or as an endorsement to their GL. Standard CGL policies exclude liquor liability for businesses in the business of selling, serving, or distributing alcohol. A restaurant tenant without liquor liability coverage has a critical gap that the landlord's additional insured status cannot overcome.

---

Tenant Improvement Coverage

When a tenant performs a build-out or tenant improvement project, the standard insurance requirements are insufficient for the construction phase.

During Construction

The tenant (or their general contractor) should carry:

• Builder's Risk coverage for the full value of the improvements during construction
• Commercial General Liability at $1,000,000/$2,000,000 (the GC's policy, with the landlord as additional insured)
• Workers' Compensation for all construction workers

The landlord should be named as a loss payee on the Builder's Risk policy. This ensures that if a fire destroys the partially completed improvements, the landlord has a direct claim under the Builder's Risk policy to restore the premises.

After Construction

Once tenant improvements are complete, the critical question is: who insures them going forward? The lease must address this clearly. The two common approaches are:

Landlord insures improvements under the building property policy. The improvements become part of the building. The landlord's property policy covers them, and the landlord recovers the cost through CAM charges or increased rent. This is the cleaner approach for improvements that will remain after the lease expires.

Tenant insures improvements under their BPP policy. The tenant treats improvements as their own property. This works for trade fixtures and specialized installations that the tenant will remove at lease end.

Ambiguity here creates disputes after a loss. The lease should specify the approach and confirm that the responsible party's coverage is adequate.

---

Enforcement and Compliance Monitoring

Requiring insurance in the lease means nothing if compliance is not enforced. The lease should include:

• A requirement to provide a certificate of insurance before occupancy — no COI, no keys
• Annual renewal requirement — the tenant must provide an updated COI at each policy renewal
• Notification of cancellation — the certificate should include a provision requiring the insurer to provide 30 days' written notice of cancellation to the landlord (note: since ACORD 25 revisions, carriers are not obligated to provide notice unless an endorsement specifically requires it)
• Landlord's right to cure — if the tenant fails to maintain required insurance, the landlord may purchase coverage on the tenant's behalf and charge the cost back as additional rent
• Consequence of non-compliance — the lease should state that failure to maintain required insurance constitutes a default under the lease

Automated COI tracking makes enforcement practical at scale. For a landlord with fifty or more tenants, manually tracking expiration dates and chasing renewals is a full-time job. A compliance platform automates the collection, verification, and monitoring process — flagging gaps before they become exposures.